- Home
- News
- Joanne McNally reveals she was rejected from Motherland, and we need her on Amandaland immediately
Joanne McNally reveals she was rejected from Motherland, and we need her on Amandaland immediately
Joanne McNally has revealed she missed out on a tiny Motherland role, and Sharon Horgan's reaction has us hoping for an Amandaland cameo.

- Ruairidh Pritchard
Published: November 20, 2026 at 4:17 PM
Save
- Share on facebook
- Share on twitter
- Share on pinterest
- Share on whatsapp
- Share on reddit
- Share on tumblr
We already knew Motherland had given us some of the greatest characters in parenting comedy history. But it turns out there was one very funny woman who almost made it into the school-gate chaos, and now we can't stop thinking about what might have been.
Ad
Comedian and Vogue Williams' podcast wife, Joanne McNally has revealed she once auditioned for Motherland, only to be rejected for a role so small she apparently didn't even have a line. Yes, really.
And now that Motherland co-creator Sharon Horgan has weighed in, we have just one question: can someone please get Joanne into Amandaland immediately?
Joanne McNally was almost in Motherland, and the role is hilarious
Speaking to Radio Times, Joanne revealed that she once tried out for a part in the BBC comedy, but didn't quite make the cut.
Want to see this content?
This page contains content provided by Instagram. We ask for your permission before anything is loaded, as Instagram may use cookies and other technologies. To view this content, choose 'Accept and continue' to allow Instagram and its required purposes.
Accept and continue
“I haven’t even held a grudge,” she joked.
And if you thought she'd been up for a major role alongside Julia, Liz or Amanda, think again.
“Now, it was Mother Number Three at the gate. I don’t even think I had a line,” she laughed.
“And I still didn’t get it, which is wild.”
Honestly, the thought of Joanne McNally being turned down for the role of a background mum at the school gates is almost too funny.
Especially when you consider just how perfectly her gloriously unfiltered sense of humour would fit into the Motherland universe.
Sharon Horgan's reaction makes it even better
Thankfully, the revelation didn't escape the attention of Sharon Horgan, who co-created Motherland and knows a thing or two about brilliantly chaotic characters.
Responding to Joanne's revelation on Instagram, Sharon appeared equally amused by the casting decision.
This is a travesty, Joanne. I’m looking into it immediately,
Sharon Horgan, Motherland co-creator
And while we're fairly sure Sharon was joking about launching an investigation into the audition, we can't help feeling there's an opportunity here.
Because if Joanne couldn't make it into Motherland, surely there's still room for her in Amandaland?
Now we need Joanne McNally in Amandaland
Just imagine it.
Joanne McNally turning up as a fellow parent who is completely unimpressed by Amanda's attempts to climb the social ladder, or even better, Anne's chaotic child-free sister? It's pratically writing itself.
And given how brilliantly Amandaland has carried on the Motherland tradition of making us laugh at the ridiculous realities of parenting, Joanne's particular brand of brutally honest comedy feels like it would fit right in.
Of course, there's absolutely no indication that Joanne is actually being considered for a role in the spin-off, and Sharon's response was very much a playful reaction to the original audition story.
But now that the idea is out there, we're struggling to let it go.
Mother Number Three might have missed her moment, but surely Amanda's world has room for one more gloriously chaotic character?
Until then, you can catch Joanne on Ed Gamble’s Unacceptable!, airing Sundays at 9pm on TLC.
Read more:
Ad
- Yoto launches huge Black Friday sale with up to 30% off audio players and cards
- Best Tonies Black Friday deals 2026 – save 20% on the Toniebox 2
- M&S kids’ Christmas knits have just landed, and prices start at £8
Authors

Ruairidh PritchardDigital Growth Lead
Ruairidh is the Digital Lead on MadeForMums. He works with a team of fantastically talented content creators and subject-matter experts on MadeForMums.
Ad
Ad
Loading...
Ad
Loading...